Mostly Asian, Thoroughly American Home Cooking
  • Home
  • Main Meals
    • Chicken and Eggs
    • Pork and Spam
    • Seafood
    • Beef and Lamb
    • Mainly Meatless
  • Sides
    • Salads
    • Vegetables
    • Rice, Bread, and Noodles
  • Treats
    • Dessert and Snacks
    • Breakfast
  • About
  • Blog

homemade tomato sauce

Picture
Three batches of ono
This is a good weekend afternoon project when your tomato plants are exploding, or when your tomatoes are a looking a little homely. It requires all of three ingredients, and the results are well-worth the time.

I opted for the 3-month shelf-life freeze method. Traditional canning included all sorts of conditions about "pressure cooking to 15PSI," and "avoiding botulism," and "make sure your jars are sterile." If you do opt for the heated/pressure canning methods, you can keep tomatoes in glass in the pantry for up to a year, but the warnings scared me off.

Homemade tomato sauce is just ono and easy to make. 


Tomatoes, about 12 big beefsteak-sized and about 8 small-to-medium sized. Any variety you want.


About 1/4 cup of red wine vinegar
Hawaiian salt to taste


Set out a deep sauce pot, a dutch oven and a large glass mixing bowl. 

Wash and core all tomatoes. On the bottom of each tomato, score an X into the skin.

PictureFresh cored tomatoes
Fill up the sauce pot with water and bring to a boil. 

While the water boils, fill the large glass mixing bowl with very cold water and enough ice to keep the water uncomfortably cold when you dunk your hand in it, but not so much that it looks like iceberg city.

When the water in the sauce pot boils, drop in a few tomatoes at a time. Let them sit for about a minute. The skins will start to peel.

Use a slotted spoon, take the tomatoes out of the boiling water and then drop them (figuratively) into the bowl of ice water. Let them sit there for about 30 seconds. While those tomatoes are sitting in their ice bath, drop the next few tomatoes into the boiling water.

Take cold tomatoes out ice water and the skins will peel off. Set them aside. Repeat until all tomatoes are peeled.

PictureHot tub, ice bath and ready for simmering
NOTE
It is very helpful to have a teenager or other assistant, but the cadence of tomato-into-boiling-water, tomato-into-ice-bath is manageable solo as well.

All the peeled tomatoes will look like those on the right.

At this point, you have two options.

#1 Dump all peeled tomatoes whole into a dutch over and mash the tomatoes with a potato peeler.

#2 Roughly chop the peeled tomatoes. (See below). 

Add Hawaiian salt and simmer tomatoes for at least 90 minutes. Stir every so often so it doesn't stick to the bottom. I used a whisk to keep the sauce a consistent texture. Add about 1/4 cup red wine vinegar at the 90-minute mark. 

PictureLet it go for 90 minutes or so
Let it simmer for about 10 more minutes and add salt or a bit more vinegar to your taste. Homemade tomato sauce starts out much more liquid-ey than store-bought sauce.

However, the longer that you let it simmer, the thicker it will get. And the flavor will get much more intense and tomato-ey. 

Pour into freezer-proof containers. If you feel like doing more work, you can start to strain out the seeds, but I did not do this. Let cool completely and then freeze. I tried to parse it out into can-like amounts. Shelf life in the freezer in three months. 

Be happy that you will have amazing spaghetti sauce, jambalaya or chili.


Follow

Chicken and Eggs
Pork and Spam
Seafood
Beef and Lamb
Mainly Meatless
Salads
Vegetables
Rice, Bread and Noodles
Dessert and Snacks
Breakfast
Blog
Glossary
Contact
Picture

©2021-2025 Feeding My Ohana. All Rights Reserved
Legal and Privacy
  • Home
  • Main Meals
    • Chicken and Eggs
    • Pork and Spam
    • Seafood
    • Beef and Lamb
    • Mainly Meatless
  • Sides
    • Salads
    • Vegetables
    • Rice, Bread, and Noodles
  • Treats
    • Dessert and Snacks
    • Breakfast
  • About
  • Blog